| Year | Season | League | Team | Playoff MVP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Int North | Colt .45s | Vincent Pelosi |
| 2014 | Spring | Int South | Dunellen Pirates (x) | |
| 2013 | Fall | Intermediate | NJ Bulldogs | |
| 2013 | Spring | Int North | Colt .45s | |
| 2013 | Spring | Int South | NJ Shockers |
(x) denotes Commissioner's Cup Champion
| Year | Season | League | Winner | Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Int North | Chris Miller | Colt .45s |
| 2014 | Spring | Int South | Angel Marte | Jersey Bombers |
| 2013 | Fall | Int North | Joe Romero | Ironbound Rays |
| 2013 | Fall | Int South | Timothy Ritchie | NJ Bulldogs |
| 2013 | Spring | Int North | Phil Mistrette | North Jersey Yellow Jackets |
| 2013 | Spring | Int South | Bill Ryan | NJ Shockers |
| Year | League | Winner | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Int North | Ray Denick | Livginston Athletics |
| 2014 | Spring | Int South | Tom Grabowski | Edison Athletics |
| 2013 | Fall | Int North | Jonathan Dominguez | Ironbound Rays |
| 2013 | Fall | Int South | Scott Horowitz | Branchburg Bullets |
| 2013 | Spring | Int North | Nick Menendez | Las Aguilas |
| 2013 | Spring | Int South | Richard Hunt | NJ Shockers |
