| Year | Season | League | Team | Playoff MVP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Premier North | Caribbean Reds | Marc Strazza |
| 2014 | Spring | Premier South | Somerville Giants (x) | Michael Judd |
| 2013 | Fall | Premier Wood | Middlesex Tigers | |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier North | Pompton Chicos | |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier South | Somerville Giants (x) |
(x) denotes Commissioner Cup Champion
| Year | Season | League | Winner | Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Premier North | Sharif Upchurch | Montclair Bulldogs |
| 2014 | Spring | Premier South | Matt Speckmann | Somerville Giants |
| 2013 | Fall | Premier Wood | Michael Maldonado | Middlesex Tigers |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier North | Sharif Upchurch | Montclair Bulldogs |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier South | H.R. Gorski | NJ Marlins |
| Year | League | Winner | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Spring | Premier North | Eric Kamp | Caribbean Reds |
| 2014 | Spring | Premier South | Mike McTamney | Garden State Senators |
| 2013 | Fall | Premier Wood | Sean Kuberiet | Middlesex Tigers |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier North | Rich Anastasi | Bergen Minutemen |
| 2013 | Spring | Premier South | Carlos Mirabal | Somerville Giants |
